Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


The First Step Is Failure

Joanne Jacobs, edu­ca­tor, blog­ger and author of Our School: The Inspir­ing Sto­ry of Two Teach­ers, One Big Idea and the Char­ter School That Beat the Odds, par­tic­i­pates today in our Author Speaks Series with an excel­lent arti­cle on how “Schools won’t improve until admin­is­tra­tors and teach­ers can admit the prob­lems, ana­lyze what’s going wrong and try new strate­gies. Stu­dents won’t improve if they think they’re “spe­cial” just the way they are.” Enjoy, and feel free to add your com­ment to engage in a stim­u­lat­ing con­ver­sa­tion.Our School: Joanne Jacobs

The First Step Is Fail­ure
By Joanne Jacobs

When self-esteem became an edu­ca­tion watch­word in 1986, I thought it was a harm­less fad. I was wrong: It wasn’t harm­less. Many teach­ers were per­suad­ed that stu­dents should be pumped up with praise, regard­less of their per­for­mance. Schools low­ered expec­ta­tions so stu­dents couldn’t fail. Every­one got an “I Am Spe­cial” stick­er. Till the stan­dards and account­abil­i­ty move­ment kicked in, stu­dents often were judged by how they felt about learn­ing not by whether they’d actu­al­ly learned some­thing.

I remem­ber a children’s book about a bad­ger (or such­like) start­ing school who’s afraid to tell his teacher he can’t read. In the denoue­ment, the teacher assures the bad­ger that she “loves” him “just the way he is.” Sure­ly not. Teach­ers can’t love all their stu­dents in any mean­ing­ful way. And the whole enter­prise of school­ing is about chang­ing chil­dren from what they are, such as illit­er­ate, to some­thing bet­ter, such as lit­er­ate. er. It’s OK to start school not know­ing how to read. It’s not OK to stay that way.

What hap­pens to those “spe­cial” chil­dren if they don’t learn how to read, write and cal­cu­late flu­ent­ly in the ear­ly grades? Even­tu­al­ly, real­i­ty bites.

I spent years hang­ing around Down­town Col­lege Prep, a San Jose char­ter high school, to write a book, Our School: The Inspir­ing Sto­ry of Two Teach­ers, One Big Idea and the Char­ter School That Beat the Odds. DCP recruits stu­dents who earned Ds and Fs in mid­dle school and tries to pre­pare them for four-year col­leges. I call it the anti-self-esteem school.

Most Down­town Col­lege Prep stu­dents come from Mex­i­can immi­grant fam­i­lies, speak Eng­lish as a sec­ond lan­guage, qual­i­fy for a free lunch, etc. They’ve got plen­ty of excus­es for fail­ure. Held to low stan­dards for years, most start ninth grade with fifth-grade read­ing and math skills and ter­ri­ble work habits.

DCP puts them in a mix of reme­di­al and col­lege-prep class­es and demands they do home­work every day and show respect for their teach­ers, class­mates and their own futures.

Hon­esty is the school pol­i­cy. No time is spent inflat­ing self-esteem. Instead, stu­dents are told that they’re way behind but have the abil­i­ty to improve if they work hard.

Stu­dents don’t crum­ble when they’re told that they’re behind. They’re not stu­pid. They already know that. What they don’t know is what to do about it. Their teach­ers tell them how to catch up, step by step. Stu­dents are praised for mak­ing progress, even if that means mov­ing from an F aver­age to an F+. But they’re remind­ed again and again that they need to pass with a C or bet­ter to qual­i­fy for a pub­lic uni­ver­si­ty. If they fail a class, they can try again in sum­mer school or repeat the grade.

If they need to spend two years in ninth grade, so be it. The school’s unof­fi­cial mot­to is: We’re not good now, but we can do bet­ter.

When Greg Lipp­man, the school’s co-founder and first prin­ci­pal, insist­ed stu­dents prac­tice pub­lic speak­ing, a teacher wor­ried they’d be embar­rassed. “I dis­agree that it’s more humil­i­at­ing to be told what you’re doing is crap­py than to have peo­ple tit­ter­ing in the audi­ence,” Lipp­man replied. “Bomb­ing out, and com­ing back from bomb­ing, is a big part of what we do here. It’s just like those PSAT scores. They were crap, garbage. OK, let’s go and get bet­ter.”

After awhile, it’s obvi­ous that stu­dents who do the work do improve.

Sel­ma, who I thought wouldn’t make it out of ninth grade, is now in col­lege study­ing to become a nurse. Anoth­er girl who’d gone through school as a straight D stu­dent came alive in 10th grade and made it to the Uni­ver­si­ty of Cal­i­for­nia at San­ta Cruz. Who knew Gina was smart? Gina will grad­u­ate in June with a psy­chol­o­gy degree and go on for a master’s in social work.

Loren­zo, who wore the “loan­er” shirt every day because he couldn’t get it togeth­er to wash the uni­form shirt, turned out to be a tal­ent­ed artist. No kind­ly adult told him that his tal­ent made it unnec­es­sary to pass read­ing, writ­ing and math tests. It took him five years to pass col­lege-prep class­es, but he made it. Loren­zo is now an art major at Chico State.

Nation­wide, about half of stu­dents who start col­lege nev­er earn a degree; most drop out in their first year. The num­bers are worse for His­pan­ic and black stu­dents.

Most DCP grad­u­ates strug­gle aca­d­e­m­i­cal­ly in col­lege, but they don’t quit: 80 per­cent are on track to earn a bachelor’s degree. Their ambi­tions are backed by basic skills, strong work habits and the resilience that comes from know­ing how to fail, try hard­er and improve.

The will­ing­ness to admit fail­ure isn’t just for stu­dents. Lipp­man and co-founder Jen­nifer Andaluz told me many of their ideas about how to edu­cate left-behind stu­dents didn’t work very well in prac­tice.

Our kids couldn’t read,” said Andaluz. “We didn’t real­ize how seri­ous the prob­lems were when we start­ed. We thought we’d get every­one to cal­cu­lus as seniors. It was just a mat­ter of engag­ing kids, moti­vat­ing them. We dis­cov­ered Mar­ta couldn’t mul­ti­ply 3 times 4.”

They scrapped the Alge­bra 1 book because stu­dents couldn’t read it. They added Eng­lish assis­tance for immi­grants. In the sec­ond year, they added reme­di­al Eng­lish and math. In the third year, they redesigned the ninth grade cur­ricu­lum, requir­ing most stu­dents to take reme­di­al cours­es in addi­tion to Eng­lish 1 and Alge­bra 1. In the fourth year, they raised stan­dards and told more stu­dents they’d need five years to be col­lege ready. And so on. Like its stu­dents, DCP is get­ting bet­ter.

Schools won’t improve until admin­is­tra­tors and teach­ers can admit the prob­lems, ana­lyze what’s going wrong and try new strate­gies. Stu­dents won’t improve if they think they’re “spe­cial” just the way they are. Many schools aren’t good now. But they can do bet­ter.

Joanne Jacobs- Our School

– Once a Knight Rid­der colum­nist, Joanne Jacobs now blogs on edu­ca­tion at

Her book, Our School: The Inspir­ing Sto­ry of Two Teach­ers, One Big Idea and the Char­ter School That Beat the Odds, is avail­able online and in book stores.

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

7 Responses

  1. Stu­dents who believe they are fail­ures will nev­er get out of the fail­ure mode. The ques­tion is how do we help them to suc­ceed, and there­by see them­selves in a new light. How do we help them to see that they are capa­ble of achiev­ing, and indeed that they can achieve at a high lev­el?

    The school men­tioned by Ms. Jacobs has deter­mined that the stu­dents will achieve and has set up a pro­gram of need­ed steps to accom­plish that goal. In order to accom­plish that objec­tive it need­ed to dis­card all pre­con­cep­tions of what is the nor­mal, stan­dard high school.

    Once stu­dents begin to achieve, their self-esteem is enhanced, not because they are told they have abil­i­ties they do not have, but because they are see­ing their progress– they are able to begin mak­ing sense of a book they are read­ing, they can speak in front of a group, or they solve alge­bra­ic equa­tions.

    It is best, how­ev­er, to have steps in the school cur­ricu­lum that can pro­vide an ear­ly inter­ven­tion and show stu­dents that they are indeed capa­ble of achieve­ment at sig­nif­i­cant lev­els.

    One of the best ways to accom­plish this objec­tive, that I am aware, is to pro­vide stu­dents while in grade school with strong suc­cess in alge­bra, such as solv­ing alge­bra­ic equa­tions which look advanced. For exam­ple, solv­ing equa­tions such as
    4x + 3 = 3x + 9 and being able to solve ver­bal prob­lems which involve such equa­tions con­veys to the stu­dents in a very con­crete man­ner that they have what it takes to suc­ceed in aca­d­e­mics.

    The Mak­ing Alge­bra Child’s Play with which I had a key role in devel­op­ing, and which are offered nation­al­ly, shows teach­ers how to use the Hands-On Equa­tions pro­gram (which I also devel­oped) to accom­plish this objec­tive.

    We are not able to say that stu­dent self-esteem is not impor­tant; it is crit­i­cal­ly impor­tant. How­ev­er, that self-esteem needs to be based on sol­id accom­plish­ment that the stu­dent sees, oth­er­wise, as Ms. Jacobs point out, it is emp­ty air.

  2. Alex Bo says:

    The first step is always hard even it isn’t fail­ure.

  3. Delia says:

    Amaz­ing to see that there are peo­ple who can see the big pic­ture! My back­ground in clin­i­cal psy­chol­o­gy high­light­ed for me that many peo­ple pre­fer to lie to them­selves and their chil­dren, as it’s eas­i­er to do that than to face the truth that you may have to make an effort, and that you may have to change if you want a dif­fer­ent result. Par­ents buy into the self-esteem delu­sion beca­sue they think it will ‘hurt’ their chil­dren to face the truth. I believe that many if not most of the prob­lems that peo­ple face, not just in edu­ca­tion, are because they can’t face the truth — it’s too painful, and if they do they’ll have to change, which ter­ri­fies them. Won­der­ful that your book shows peo­ple that fac­ing the truth is so much bet­ter than run­ning from it. Thank you!

  4. Alvaro says:

    Dear Hen­ry: thank you for a beau­ti­ful com­ment. I recent­ly sat at a pan­el with Car­ol Dweck as she talked about her “Growth Mind­set” research. What Joanne stress­es, and you illus­trate, is that we (learn­ers of all ages) need to dif­fer­en­ti­ate between “being a fail­ure” and “hav­ing a fail­ure”. I agree that stu­dents need to devel­op authen­tic self esteem-the only one they will inter­nal­ize, in any case.

    I am very curi­ous now about your alge­bra method: we’ll take a look at your web­site dur­ing the next month. And you should feel free to con­tribute to this blog in the same way Joanne has.

    Delia: thank you for your com­ment too. Will make sure Joanne sees it. I can imag­ine how this is rel­e­vant to your work in clin­i­cal psy­chol­o­gy, espe­cial­ly if you prac­tice cog­ni­tive ther­a­py…

    Alex: I’d say the first step is always the first step. Why is it always hard? maybe we make it so?

  5. Pat says:

    This was a great sto­ry. As a spe­cial edu­ca­tion teacher, I see so much poten­tial in my stu­dents but the gen­er­al expec­ta­tion is for them to fail so the stu­dents believe they will. I set high stan­dards for my stu­dents and expect them to achieve, which sur­pris­es a lot of teach­ers, par­ents and stu­dents. The only not sur­prised is myself. It is time for all edu­ca­tors to get on board with this phi­los­o­phy.

  6. Angevahn says:

    I agree that this is a great sto­ry, and inter­est­ing com­ments too. As a Mas­ter Facil­i­ta­tor with The Virtues Project I pass on to oth­ers 5 sim­ple strate­gies for devel­op­ing authen­tic self-esteem — a pos­i­tive and real­is­tic sense of self that comes from with­in, that is inter­nalised. Giv­ing chil­dren feed­back regards the char­ac­ter traits they exhib­it and guid­ance as to what oth­er char­ac­ter traits are required is a pow­er­ful tool for devel­op­ing mas­tery with­in chil­dren. They all have these traits — as do we — how­ev­er, they may nev­er have been asked to show dili­gence (as opposed to work­ing hard­er), acknowl­edged for their perserver­ance or been called to prac­tise excel­lence. We do our best by chil­dren in believ­ing they are capa­ble, being real­is­tic as to what the cur­rent sit­u­a­tion is, and being able to inspire them and empow­er them to grow from there. In the end, we want more kids like those described — with the inter­nal resources to pick them­selves up after a fail­ure — whether that is with edu­ca­tion learn­ing, or life learn­ing, be able to grasp what change in behav­iour / atti­tude is required, and get back in there.

  7. Alvaro says:

    Hel­lo Pat and Angevahn: thank you for adding your per­spec­tives and expe­ri­ences!

Leave a Reply

Categories: Author Speaks Series, Education & Lifelong Learning

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters and more, SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking health and performance applications of brain science.

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

Search for anything brain-related in our article archives