Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


The State of Mindfulness Science: 10 Key Research Findings to Encourage and Guide your Meditation Practice in 2018


Dur­ing the past two decades, more and more sci­en­tists have stud­ied mindfulness—a Bud­dhist-inspired col­lec­tion of prac­tices aimed at help­ing us to cul­ti­vate moment-to-moment aware­ness of our­selves and our envi­ron­ment. Their ear­ly find­ings trig­gered an enor­mous amount of enthu­si­asm for med­i­ta­tion.

Some­times, how­ev­er, jour­nal­ists and even sci­en­tists (who should know bet­ter) have over­stat­ed the phys­i­cal and men­tal health ben­e­fits, which has fed grow­ing skep­ti­cism about mind­ful­ness.

Indeed, the sci­ence behind mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion has often suf­fered from poor research designs and small effect sizes, as 15 psy­chol­o­gists and neu­ro­sci­en­tists found after review­ing hun­dreds of mind­ful­ness stud­ies. Their paper, pub­lished in Octo­ber by Per­spec­tives on Psy­cho­log­i­cal Sci­ence, argues that there is still much we don’t under­stand about mind­ful­ness and med­i­ta­tion. Worse, many sci­en­tists and prac­ti­tion­ers don’t even agree on the def­i­n­i­tion of those words. They end the paper call­ing for “truth in adver­tis­ing by con­tem­pla­tive neu­ro­science.”

In that spir­it, here’s a run­down of ques­tions that seem fair­ly set­tled, for the time being, and ques­tions researchers are still explor­ing.

1. Meditation almost certainly does sharpen your attention

It’s not sur­pris­ing that med­i­ta­tion would affect atten­tion, since many prac­tices focus on this very skill. And, in fact, researchers have found that med­i­ta­tion helps to counter habituation—the ten­den­cy to stop pay­ing atten­tion to new infor­ma­tion in our envi­ron­ment. Oth­er stud­ies have found that mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion can reduce mind-wan­der­ing and improve our abil­i­ty to solve prob­lems.

There’s more good news: Stud­ies have shown that improved atten­tion seems to last up to five years after mind­ful­ness train­ing, again sug­gest­ing trait-like changes are pos­si­ble.

Do these ben­e­fits apply to peo­ple with atten­tion-deficit dis­or­ders, and could med­i­ta­tion pos­si­bly sup­plant drugs like Adder­all? We can’t yet say for sure. While there have been some promis­ing small-scale stud­ies, espe­cial­ly with adults, we need larg­er ran­dom­ized con­trolled tri­als to under­stand how med­i­ta­tion might mix with oth­er treat­ments to help both kids and adults man­age atten­tion-deficits.

2. Long-term, consistent meditation does seem to increase resiliency to stress

Note that we’re not say­ing it nec­es­sar­i­ly reduces phys­i­o­log­i­cal and psy­cho­log­i­cal reac­tions to threats and obsta­cles. But stud­ies to date do sug­gest that med­i­ta­tion helps mind and body bounce back from stress and stress­ful sit­u­a­tions.

For exam­ple, prac­tic­ing med­i­ta­tion lessens the inflam­ma­to­ry response in peo­ple exposed to psy­cho­log­i­cal stres­sors, par­tic­u­lar­ly for long-term med­i­ta­tors. Accord­ing to neu­ro­science research, mind­ful­ness prac­tices damp­en activ­i­ty in our amyg­dala and increase the con­nec­tions between the amyg­dala and pre­frontal cor­tex. Both of these parts of the brain help us to be less reac­tive to stres­sors and to recov­er bet­ter from stress when we expe­ri­ence it.

As Daniel Gole­man and Richard David­son write in their new book, Altered Traits, “These changes are trait-like: They appear not sim­ply dur­ing the explic­it instruc­tion to per­ceive the stress­ful stim­uli mind­ful­ly, but even in the ‘base­line’ state” for longer-term med­i­ta­tors, which sup­ports the pos­si­bil­i­ty that mind­ful­ness changes our abil­i­ty to han­dle stress in a bet­ter, more sus­tain­able way.”

3. Meditation does appear to increase compassion. It also makes our compassion more effective.

While we may espouse com­pas­sion­ate atti­tudes, we can also suf­fer when we see oth­ers suf­fer­ing, which can cre­ate a state of paral­y­sis or with­draw­al.

Many well-designed stud­ies have shown that prac­tic­ing lov­ing-kind­ness med­i­ta­tion for oth­ers increas­es our will­ing­ness to take action to relieve suf­fer­ing. It appears to do this by less­en­ing amyg­dala activ­i­ty in the pres­ence of suf­fer­ing, while also acti­vat­ing cir­cuits in the brain that are con­nect­ed to good feel­ings and love.

For long­time med­i­ta­tors, activ­i­ty in the “default network”—the part of our brains that, when not busy with focused activ­i­ty, rumi­nates on thoughts, feel­ings, and experiences—quiets down, sug­gest­ing less rumi­na­tion about our­selves and our place in the world.

4. Meditation does seem to improve mental health—but it’s not necessarily more effective than other steps you can take

Ear­ly research sug­gest­ed that mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion had a dra­mat­ic impact on our men­tal health. But as the num­ber of stud­ies has grown, so has sci­en­tif­ic skep­ti­cism about these ini­tial claims.

For exam­ple, a 2014 meta-analy­sis pub­lished in JAMA Inter­nal Med­i­cine exam­ined 47 ran­dom­ized con­trolled tri­als of mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion pro­grams, which includ­ed a total of 3,515 par­tic­i­pants. They found that med­i­ta­tion pro­grams result­ed only in small to mod­er­ate reduc­tions in anx­i­ety and depres­sion. Fur­ther­more, there was also low, insuf­fi­cient, or no evi­dence of med­i­ta­tion pro­grams’ effect on pos­i­tive mood and feel­ings and sub­stance use (as well as phys­i­cal self-care like eat­ing habits and sleep).

Accord­ing to the authors, med­i­ta­tion pro­grams were not shown to be more ben­e­fi­cial than active treatments—such as exer­cise, ther­a­py, or tak­ing pre­scrip­tion drugs—on any out­comes of inter­est.

The research is also rais­ing some inter­est­ing nuances about the effec­tive­ness of med­i­ta­tion for dif­fer­ent pop­u­la­tions. For exam­ple, one recent, large-scale, well-designed study found that the “gold stan­dard” Mind­ful­ness Based Stress Reduc­tion (MBSR) inter­ven­tion for adults had no impact on depres­sion or anx­i­ety in teens. As the authors note, this doesn’t mean med­i­ta­tion can’t help teenagers—it could well be the case that we need to devel­op and test inter­ven­tions aimed at younger peo­ple.

The upshot? Med­i­ta­tion is gen­er­al­ly good for your well-being, yes, but so far it doesn’t appear to be actu­al­ly bet­ter than many oth­er steps you can take to stay healthy and hap­py. It should def­i­nite­ly be con­sid­ered an adjunct to, not a replace­ment for, oth­er kinds of treat­ment for men­tal con­di­tions like bipo­lar dis­or­der.

5. Mindfulness could have a positive impact on your relationships

There are many, many stud­ies that find a pos­i­tive link between mind­ful­ness and rela­tion­ship qual­i­ty, which is prob­a­bly a byprod­uct of the effects we’ve already described.

For exam­ple, in one 2016 study, researchers mea­sured mind­ful­ness in 88 cou­ples. Then they took cor­ti­sol lev­els in each cou­ple before and after they dis­cussed a con­flict in their rela­tion­ship. Unsur­pris­ing­ly, cor­ti­sol lev­els spiked dur­ing the dis­cus­sion, a sign of high stress. But lev­els in the most mind­ful people—both men and women—were quick­er to return to nor­mal after the con­flict end­ed, sug­gest­ing they were keep­ing their cool.

This result is echoed in many stud­ies of mind­ful­ness in roman­tic rela­tion­ships from the begin­ning to the very end—in fact, there are quite a few stud­ies that find that mind­ful­ness makes breakup and divorce eas­i­er.

Mind­ful­ness is also linked to bet­ter rela­tion­ships with your kids. Stud­ies have found that mind­ful­ness prac­tice can lessen stress, depres­sion, and anx­i­ety in par­ents of preschool­ers and chil­dren with dis­abil­i­ties. Mind­ful par­ent­ing is also linked to more pos­i­tive behav­ior in kids.

A small 2016 pilot study used neu­roimag­ing to see how mind­ful­ness prac­tice changes the brains of parents—and then asked the kids about the qual­i­ty of their par­ent­ing. The results sug­gest that mind­ful­ness prac­tice seemed to acti­vate the part of the brain involved in empa­thy and emo­tion­al reg­u­la­tion (the left ante­ri­or insula/inferior frontal gyrus) and that the chil­dren of par­ents who showed the most acti­va­tion per­ceived the great­est improve­ment in the par­ent-child rela­tion­ship.

We must remem­ber, how­ev­er, that these stud­ies are often very small, and the researchers them­selves say results are very ten­ta­tive.

6. Mindfulness seems to reduce many kinds of bias

We are see­ing more and more stud­ies sug­gest­ing that prac­tic­ing mind­ful­ness can reduce psy­cho­log­i­cal bias.

For exam­ple, one study found that a brief lov­ing-kind­ness med­i­ta­tion reduced prej­u­dice toward home­less peo­ple, while anoth­er found that a brief mind­ful­ness train­ing decreased uncon­scious bias against black peo­ple and elder­ly peo­ple. In a study by Adam Lueke and col­leagues, white par­tic­i­pants who received a brief mind­ful­ness train­ing demon­strat­ed less biased behav­ior (not just atti­tudes) toward black par­tic­i­pants in a trust game.

How­ev­er, social bias isn’t the only kind of men­tal bias mind­ful­ness appears to reduce. For exam­ple, sev­er­al stud­ies con­vinc­ing­ly show that mind­ful­ness prob­a­bly reduces sunk-cost bias, which is our ten­den­cy to stay invest­ed in a los­ing propo­si­tion.

Mind­ful­ness also seems to reduce our nat­ur­al ten­den­cy to focus on the neg­a­tive things in life. In one study, par­tic­i­pants report­ed on their gen­er­al mind­ful­ness lev­els, then briefly viewed pho­tos that induced strong pos­i­tive emo­tion (like pho­tos of babies), strong neg­a­tive emo­tion (like pho­tos of peo­ple in pain), or nei­ther, while hav­ing their brains scanned. More mind­ful par­tic­i­pants were less reac­tive to neg­a­tive pho­tos and showed high­er indi­ca­tions of pos­i­tive feel­ing when see­ing the pos­i­tive pho­tos. Accord­ing to the authors, this sup­ports the con­tention that mind­ful­ness decreas­es the neg­a­tiv­i­ty bias, some­thing oth­er stud­ies sup­port, too.

7. Meditation does have an impact on physical health—but it’s modest

Many claims have been made about mind­ful­ness and phys­i­cal health, but some­times these claims are hard to sub­stan­ti­ate or may be mixed up with oth­er effects. That said, there is some good evi­dence that med­i­ta­tion affects phys­i­o­log­i­cal indices of health.

We’ve already men­tioned that long-term med­i­ta­tion seems to buffer peo­ple from the inflam­ma­to­ry response to stress. In addi­tion, med­i­ta­tors seem to have increased activ­i­ty of telom­erase, an enzyme impli­cat­ed in longer cell life and, there­fore, longevi­ty.

But there’s a catch. “The dif­fer­ences found [between med­i­ta­tors and non-med­i­ta­tors] could be due to fac­tors like edu­ca­tion or exer­cise, each of which has its own buffer­ing effect on brains,” write Gole­man and David­son in Altered Traits. “Then there’s self-selec­tion: Per­haps peo­ple with the brain changes report­ed in these stud­ies choose to stick with med­i­ta­tion while oth­ers do not.” In oth­er words, we should use cau­tion when cham­pi­oning results.

8. Meditation might not be good for everyone all the time

Some seem to believe mind­ful­ness prac­tice will invari­ably induce a sense of peace and calm. While this can be the expe­ri­ence for many, it is not the expe­ri­ence for all. At times, sit­ting qui­et­ly with one­self can be a difficult—even painful—experience. For indi­vid­u­als who have expe­ri­enced some sort of trau­ma, sit­ting and med­i­tat­ing can at times bring up recent or some­times decades-old painful mem­o­ries and expe­ri­ences that they may not be pre­pared to con­front.

In a new study pub­lished in the jour­nal PLoS ONE, Jared Lin­dahl and col­leagues inter­viewed 100 med­i­ta­tors about “chal­leng­ing” expe­ri­ences. They found that many of them expe­ri­enced fear, anx­i­ety, pan­ic, numb­ness, or extreme sen­si­tiv­i­ty to light and sound that they attrib­uted to med­i­ta­tion. Cru­cial­ly, they found that these expe­ri­ences weren’t restrict­ed to peo­ple with “pre-exist­ing” con­di­tions, like trau­ma or men­tal ill­ness; they could hap­pen to any­one at any time.

In this new domain of research, there is still a lot we do not under­stand. Future research needs to explore the rela­tion­ship between case his­to­ries and med­i­ta­tion expe­ri­ences, how the type of prac­tice relates to chal­leng­ing expe­ri­ences, and the influ­ence of oth­er fac­tors like social sup­port.

9. What kind of meditation is right for you? That depends.

Mind­ful­ness” is a big umbrel­la that cov­ers many dif­fer­ent kinds of prac­tice. A 2016 study com­pared four dif­fer­ent types of med­i­ta­tion, and found that they each have their own unique ben­e­fits.

Dur­ing body scan, for exam­ple, par­tic­i­pants saw the biggest increas­es in how aware they were of their bod­ies (unsur­pris­ing­ly) and the sharpest decline in the num­ber of thoughts they were hav­ing, par­tic­u­lar­ly neg­a­tive thoughts and thoughts relat­ed to the past and future. Lov­ing-kind­ness med­i­ta­tion led to the great­est boost in their feel­ings of warmth and pos­i­tive thoughts about oth­ers. Mean­while, observ­ing-thought med­i­ta­tion seemed to increase par­tic­i­pants’ aware­ness of their thoughts the most. Pre­vi­ous research also sug­gests that observ­ing-thought med­i­ta­tion has an advan­tage in reduc­ing our judg­men­tal atti­tude toward oth­ers.

Tak­en togeth­er, these and oth­er stud­ies sug­gest that if you’re tack­ling a spe­cif­ic issue—say, feel­ing dis­con­nect­ed from your body—then you can choose a prac­tice aimed at help­ing that issue, like the body scan. Lov­ing-kind­ness might help in con­flict with oth­ers, while observ­ing-thought med­i­ta­tion can help break rumi­na­tion.

The type of med­i­ta­tion mat­ters,” explain post­doc­tor­al researcher Bethany Kok and pro­fes­sor Tania Singer. “Each prac­tice appears to cre­ate a dis­tinct men­tal envi­ron­ment, the long-term con­se­quences of which are only begin­ning to be explored.”

10. How much meditation is enough? That also depends.

This isn’t the answer most peo­ple want to hear. Many of us are look­ing for a med­ical­ly pre­scrip­tive response (e.g., three times a week for 45–60 min­utes), but the best guide might be this old Zen say­ing: “You should sit in med­i­ta­tion for twen­ty min­utes every day—unless you’re too busy. Then you should sit for an hour.”

To date, empir­i­cal research has yet to arrive at a con­sen­sus about how much is “enough.” Aside from the raw num­ber of min­utes, oth­er fac­tors may inter­act to influ­ence the ben­e­fits of mind­ful­ness prac­tice: the type (e.g., for­mal sit­ting med­i­ta­tion prac­tice vs. infor­mal med­i­ta­tion prac­tices, mind­ful­ness vs. com­pas­sion, etc.), the fre­quen­cy (mul­ti­ple times a day vs. mul­ti­ple times a week), and the qual­i­ty (sit­ting and actu­al­ly doing the prac­tice vs. doing the prac­tice “on the go”). While it’s pos­si­ble that in the next 10–15 years we will see a CDC-style rec­om­men­da­tion regard­ing med­i­ta­tion prac­tice, to date, the empir­i­cal data on the top­ic are still incon­clu­sive.

Our rec­om­men­da­tion? Try out dif­fer­ent dura­tions, types, and fre­quen­cies of med­i­ta­tion and jot down how you feel before and after the practice—and see what seems to work for you.

Greater Good staff and writ­ers Jere­my Adam Smith, Kira M. New­man, Hoo­ria Jazaieri and Jill Sut­tie pre­pared this arti­cle for Lion’s Roar Mag­a­zine. Based at UC-Berke­ley, Greater Good high­lights ground break­ing sci­en­tif­ic research into the roots of com­pas­sion and altru­ism. Copy­right Greater Good.

Related articles


Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Categories: Cognitive Neuroscience, Education & Lifelong Learning, Health & Wellness

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Search in our Archives

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters,  SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking how brain science can improve our health and our lives.

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)