Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Icon

When 1 + 1 = 5: Dyscalculia and Working Memory

Jacob’s moth­er writes that ‘Jacob, 10-years-old, still strug­gles with num­ber bonds to 10. Learn­ing to tell the time is still slow – he has not mas­tered half-past. Although he man­aged to learn his 5x tables because we prac­ticed all sum­mer, this has now gone’.

Jacob has dyscal­cu­lia, a math dis­abil­i­ty where stu­dents strug­gle to learn or under­stand math­e­mat­ics. Stu­dents with dyscal­cu­lia find it dif­fi­cult to deci­pher math sym­bols (e.g. +, –), count­ing prin­ci­ples (‘two’ stands for 2), solv­ing arith­metic prob­lems, and usu­al­ly trans­pose num­bers (e.g. 75 becomes 57). How­ev­er, dyscal­cu­lia encom­pass­es more than prob­lems with num­bers – there is also a strug­gle with telling the time as in Jacob’s case, iden­ti­fy­ing left from right, and rec­og­niz­ing pat­terns.

But why do some stu­dents strug­gle to learn num­bers and cer­tain math­e­mat­i­cal prin­ci­ples?

Work­ing Mem­o­ry plays a key role. To solve a math­e­mat­i­cal prob­lem like 1 + 1, we need to use our Visuo-Spa­tial Work­ing Mem­o­ry. Visuo–spatial work­ing mem­o­ry func­tions like a big men­tal black­board that gives us a space to write all of the num­bers nec­es­sary to solve a prob­lem.

It also works togeth­er with the brain’s cal­cu­la­tor known as the Intra­pari­etal Sul­cus (IPS), locat­ed in the right hemi­sphere. Brain imag­ing stud­ies that looked at brain activ­i­ty while peo­ple were count­ing and cal­cu­lat­ing quan­ti­ties reveal that when we count, regard­less of whether it is shapes, num­bers, or objects, the IPS is acti­vat­ed. In dyscal­culics, this area under­per­forms and may under­pin their maths dif­fi­cul­ties.

Like Jacob, the stu­dent with dyscal­cu­lia has clear work­ing mem­o­ry deficits. How­ev­er, the link between work­ing mem­o­ry and math skills depends on the age of the child as well as the type of math task. Ver­bal work­ing mem­o­ry plays a strong role in math skills in sev­en-year-olds and is a reli­able indi­ca­tor of dyscal­cu­lia in the first year of for­mal school­ing. Once chil­dren reach ado­les­cence, ver­bal work­ing mem­o­ry is no longer sig­nif­i­cant­ly linked to math­e­mat­i­cal skills. One expla­na­tion for this change is that ver­bal work­ing mem­o­ry plays a cru­cial role for basic arith­metic skills like learn­ing arith­metic rules and retain­ing rel­e­vant data such as car­ried dig­its when they are young. How­ev­er, as chil­dren get old­er oth­er fac­tors such as num­ber knowl­edge and strate­gies play a greater role.

If you are work­ing with a stu­dent with dyscal­cu­lia, it is impor­tant not only to address their dif­fi­cul­ties with num­bers, but to also assess their Work­ing Mem­o­ry. It is pos­si­ble that they have a small men­tal black­board (visuo-spa­tial Work­ing Mem­o­ry) that is mak­ing it hard­er for them to apply their num­ber knowl­edge in a class­room sit­u­a­tion.

tracy_pic– Tra­cy Pack­iam Alloway, PhD, is an Assis­tant Pro­fes­sor at the Uni­ver­si­ty of North Flori­da. She was recent­ly award­ed the pres­ti­gious Joseph Lis­ter Award by the British Sci­ence Asso­ci­a­tion for her con­tri­bu­tion to sci­ence. Tra­cy devel­oped a stan­dard­ized work­ing-mem­o­ry tests for edu­ca­tors pub­lished by Psy­cho­log­i­cal Cor­po­ra­tion, which to date has been trans­lated into 15 lan­guages and used to screen for work­ing mem­ory prob­lems in stu­dents with dyslex­ia, motor dys­praxia (Devel­op­men­tal Coor­di­na­tion Dis­or­der), ADHD and Autis­tic Spec­trum Dis­or­der. She pro­vides con­sul­tancy to the World Bank and her research has received wide­spread inter­na­tional cov­er­age in hun­dreds of media out­lets, includ­ing Sci­en­tific Amer­i­can, the BBC, Reuters, ABC News, and NBC.

Ref­er­ence

Alloway, T.P. & Pas­sol­unghi, MC. (2011). The rela­tions between work­ing mem­o­ry and arith­meti­cal abil­i­ties: A com­par­i­son between Ital­ian and British chil­dren. Learn­ing and Indi­vid­ual Dif­fer­ences, 21, 133–137.

To learn more:

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

4 Responses

  1. Are the neu­ro­phys­i­cal cor­re­lates of work­ing mem­ory deficits the result of bio­log­i­cal­ly ordained structural/processing insuf­fi­cien­cies (mal­adap­tive bio-devel­op­ment) (1) or are the neu­ro-phys­i­o­log­i­cal cor­re­lates of work­ing mem­o­ry deficits the result of a lack of neu­ro­phys­i­cal exercise/activity due to learned mal­ad­pa­tive pro­cess­ing schema? For a relat­ed exam­ple, a recent study of dyslex­ia moved us clos­er to under­stand­ing the sig­na­ture of dyslex­ia pri­or to begin­ning read­ing (http://www.medpagetoday.com/Neurology/GeneralNeurology/30835) but here too the test­ing is far down­stream from the influ­ence of ear­ly learn­ing. Isn’t dis­en­tan­gling the genet­i­cal­ly-deter­mined from the learn­ing-formed much more sub­tle than we are acknowl­edg­ing? Are the brain dif­fer­ences cor­re­lat­ed with mem­o­ry deficits described here exclu­sive­ly the result of gene-for­ma­tive process­es or could there be a much deep­er and rich­er and more sub­tle realm of ear­ly learn­ing that can also result in the brain dif­fer­ences you are describ­ing?

  2. Tracy says:

    Hi David, thanks for tak­ing the time to com­ment. It looks like there are at least 3 ques­tions here, so I will try to address them in turn (and briefly!). The first ques­tion seems to me to be why some chil­dren have WM deficits, while oth­ers don’t. This is a tricky one and the jury is still out. We do know that WM is not great­ly affect­ed by envi­ron­men­tal fac­tors (eg, finan­cial back­ground, mother’s edu­ca­tion­al lev­el, etc), unlike oth­er cog­ni­tive skills in gen­er­al abil­i­ty (IQ scores). So why do some kids strug­gle: one pos­si­bil­i­ty is they start off with a small­er WM (or ‘post-it-note’ as I have referred to it in the past). Anoth­er pos­si­bil­i­ty is that for some rea­son they are not able to use all of their WM capac­i­ty, some­times b/c of stress or anx­i­ety. So although they have the capac­i­ty to do well, they are not max­i­miz­ing it.
    Q2: Genet­ics. There is some research (and I am in the midst of com­plet­ing some as well) indi­cat­ing there is a a strong genet­ic com­po­nent to WM capac­i­ty. This idea fits well with my pre­vi­ous point about WM being min­i­mal­ly affect­ed by envi­ron­men­tal fac­tors.
    Q3: Brain dif­fer­ences: The ques­tion could be rephrased to look at whether there is less acti­va­tion when some peo­ple use WM to solve a prob­lem, vs brain size (cor­ti­cal thick­ness, etc). We do know that low­er scores on WM tests are linked to less brain acti­va­tion in the PFC. How­ev­er, there is less research on actu­al brain size and WM scores. Hope this helps.

  3. Thank for this arti­cle Doc­tor. Would the math issue be less­ened if the musi­cal part of the brain was used to assist?

    My father vol­un­teered using pro­to­cols from what was the Philadel­phia Brain Injury Clin­ic. Despite hav­ing lost 1/2 his brain in a trag­ic auto acci­dent (he was a bystander) with a very reg­i­ment­ed 14 hour+ day of ther­a­py his recov­ery from giv­en up for dead to mid lev­el func­tion was amaz­ing.

    Thank you for shar­ing this insight.

    I’m a gen­er­al­ist in the field of resilien­cy.
    One of our pro­grams helps fos­ter par­ents, grand par­ents, par­ents of spe­cial needs chil­dren learn key skills to assist them gain some added self-aware­ness and self-man­age­ment skills

    https://www.facebook.com/InnerResilience

    Michael
    Toron­to Cana­da

  4. P.S. I should have said my father was one of the vol­un­teers help­ing the gen­tle­man that had been seri­ous­ly injured.

Leave a Reply

Categories: Education & Lifelong Learning

Tags: , , , , ,

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters and more, SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking health and performance applications of brain science.

Follow us and Engage via…

twitter_logo_header
RSS Feed

Search for anything brain-related in our article archives