Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


Math Brain Teaser: Concentric Shapes or The Unkindest Cut of All, Part 2 of 2

If you missed Part 1, also writ­ten by puz­zle mas­ter Wes Car­roll, you can start there and then come back here to Part 2.

Con­cen­tric Shapes:
The Unkind­est Cut of All, Part 2 of 2

Dif­fi­cul­ty: HARDER
Type: MATH (Spa­tial)
Vitruvian Man

Imag­ine a square with­in a cir­cle with­in a square. The cir­cle just grazes each square at exact­ly four points. Find the ratio of the area of the larg­er square to the small­er.

In this puz­zle you are work­ing out many of the same skills as in Part I: spa­tial visu­al­iza­tion (occip­i­tal lobes), mem­o­ry (tem­po­ral lobes), log­ic (frontal lobes), plan­ning (frontal lobes), and hypoth­e­sis gen­er­a­tion (frontal lobes).

Two to one.

Draw the small­er square’s diag­o­nal to see that the the small­er square’s diag­o­nal is the diam­e­ter of the cir­cle. Divide the larg­er square into two equal rec­tan­gu­lar halves to see that the larg­er square’s side is also the diam­e­ter of the cir­cle. This means that the small­er square’s diag­o­nal equals the larg­er square’s side. (Or, if you pre­fer, sim­ply rotate the inner square by 45 degrees.) As we’ve seen in the ear­li­er puz­zle “The Unkind­est Cut Of All,” the area of the small­er square is half that of the larg­er, mak­ing the ratio two to one.


More brain teas­er games:

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

8 Responses

  1. stefan says:

    I mis-read the instruc­tions to be the oppo­site: an out­er cir­cle, a square inside that and anoth­er cir­cle inside the square, and calc the area dif­fer­ence between the *cir­cles*. Per­haps I looked at the pic­ture instead of read the instruc­tions!

    Any­way, I solved it with trig (draw a right tri­an­gle with one point in the cen­ter, anoth­er to a cor­ner of the square and anoth­er to a near side of the square). The area of each cir­cle can be derived from the length of the short­er side.

    Inter­est­ing­ly, it comes out to the same answer: the out­er cir­cle is twice the area of the small­er one!

  2. Caroline says:

    I think you cre­at­ed a more dif­fi­cult brain teas­er! Nice solu­tion. Now we just need to strength­en those read­ing atten­tion skills! 😉 (sor­ry if the pic­ture was mis­lead­ing — I just like the pic­ture and thought it went with the theme, if not the specifics)

  3. T ROY says:



  4. Peter Cooper says:

    I did it by say­ing that the out­er square’s area is x^2. The inter­nal square’s diag­o­nal length must be x, so its per­pen­dic­u­lar length must be the square root of x^2 / 2 (Pythagorus). Squar­ing that undoes the square root, so you get x^2 com­pared to x^2 / 2. Fac­tor­ing down the x^2 to 1, we get 1/0.5.. or 2/1.

  5. whoop says:

    Its easy if you real­ize that the radius of the cir­cle is both half the diag­o­nal of the small­er square and half the side val­ue of the larg­er square.

  6. easyas123 says:

    quite easy, i like those kind of prob­lems

  7. Egon_Freeman says:

    I arrived at this con­clu­sion through “graz­ing both squares in exact­ly 4 points” — cor­ners of the small­er one, and the ‘cen­ters’ of walls of the big­ger one.

    Pri­mar­i­ly through “spa­tial rea­son­ing”, rotat­ed the inner square, and arrived at a point stat­ed in the pre­vi­ous puz­zle.

    10 sec­onds. Once again, change it to “Easy” (esp. if some­one solved, or at least read, the pre­vi­ous puz­zle).

Leave a Reply

Categories: Brain Teasers

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Search in our archives

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters,  SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking how brain science can improve our health and our lives.

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)