Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


Study: To treat depression, therapy alone works better than therapy combined with antidepressants


Should Com­bined CBT, Phar­ma­cother­a­py Be Recon­sid­ered in MDD? (Psy­chi­a­try Advi­sor):

Cog­ni­tive behav­ioral ther­a­py (CBT) alone proved to be supe­ri­or to the com­bi­na­tion of psy­chother­a­py and anti­de­pres­sant med­ica­tion in the treat­ment of major depres­sive dis­or­der (MDD) in a sys­tem­at­ic review and meta-analy­sis pub­lished in Psy­cho­log­i­cal Med­i­cine.

Anti­de­pres­sant med­ica­tion is asso­ci­at­ed with side effects and with­draw­al symp­toms and 23% more expen­sive than psy­cho­log­i­cal inter­ven­tions, which patients often pre­fer. Evi­dence has also sug­gest­ed that CBT and inter­per­son­al psy­chother­a­py (IPT) may be equal­ly effec­tive though lit­tle is known about com­par­isons of CBT and IPT, or either in com­bi­na­tion with anti­de­pres­sant med­ica­tion … The researchers con­tend that “con­sid­er­ing the supe­ri­or­i­ty of CBT alone and the side-effects, taper­ing prob­lems and with­draw­al symp­toms asso­ci­at­ed with [anti­de­pres­sant med­ica­tions], com­bined treat­ment should be pre­scribed care­ful­ly, only in com­plex cas­es and on a case-by-case basis.”

The Study:

Towards per­son­al­is­ing treat­ment: a sys­tem­at­ic review and meta-analy­sis of face-to-face effi­ca­cy mod­er­a­tors of cog­ni­tive-behav­ioral ther­a­py and inter­per­son­al psy­chother­a­py for major depres­sive dis­or­der (Psy­cho­log­i­cal Med­i­cine). From the abstract:

  • Back­ground: Con­sis­tent evi­dence sug­gests that face-to-face cog­ni­tive-behav­iour­al ther­a­py (CBT) and inter­per­son­al psy­chother­a­py (IPT) may be equal­ly effec­tive depres­sion treat­ments. Cur­rent clin­i­cal research focus­es on detect­ing the best pre­dic­tors-mod­er­a­tors of effi­ca­cy to guide treat­ment per­son­al­i­sa­tion. How­ev­er, indi­vid­ual mod­er­a­tor stud­ies show incon­sis­tent find­ings. This sys­tem­at­ic review and meta-analy­sis aimed to com­pare the effi­ca­cy of CBT and IPT, includ­ing com­bined treat­ment with anti­de­pres­sants for depres­sion, and eval­u­ate the pre­dic­tive pow­er of demo­graph­ic, clin­i­cal pre­sen­ta­tion and treat­ment char­ac­ter­is­tics mod­er­a­tors for both ther­a­pies.
  • Meth­ods: Psy­cAr­ti­cles, PsycIN­FO, PubMed and Cochrane Library were sys­tem­at­i­cal­ly searched through Decem­ber 2017 for stud­ies that have assessed indi­vid­u­als with major depres­sion receiv­ing either CBT or IPT in a face-to-face for­mat both at pre- and post-treat­ment. Ran­dom-effects mod­er­a­tor meta-analy­ses were con­duct­ed.
  • Results: In total 168 sam­ples from 137 stud­ies includ­ing 11 374 par­tic­i­pants qual­i­fied for the meta-ana­lyt­ic review. CBT and IPT were equal­ly effec­tive across all but one pre­spec­i­fied mod­er­a­tors. For psy­chother­a­py deliv­ered with­out con­comi­tant anti­de­pres­sant treat­ment [anti­de­pres­sant med­ica­tions (ADMs)], CBT was supe­ri­or to IPT (g = 1.68, Qbe­tweenp = 0.037). With­in-CBT mod­er­a­tor analy­ses showed that increased CBT effi­ca­cy was asso­ci­at­ed with low­er age, high ini­tial depres­sion sever­i­ty, indi­vid­ual for­mat of admin­is­tra­tion and no adjunc­tive ADMs. With­in-IPT analy­ses showed com­pa­ra­ble effi­ca­cy across all mod­er­a­tors.
  • Con­clu­sions: Clin­i­cal guid­ance around com­bined treat­ment (psy­chother­a­py plus ADMs) should be recon­sid­ered. CBT alone is supe­ri­or to IPT alone and to com­bined treat­ment, while IPT alone is non-infe­ri­or to com­bined treat­ment. More research is need­ed to assess the mod­er­at­ing effect of old­er age and num­ber of pre­vi­ous episodes on IPT effi­ca­cy.

The Study in Context:

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Categories: Cognitive Neuroscience, Health & Wellness

Tags: , , , ,

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters,  SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking how brain science can improve our health and our lives.

Search in our archives

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)