Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


Mindfully debunking four meditation myths


Mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion can help us lead hap­pi­er, health­i­er lives … at least accord­ing to sci­ence. Yet many of us still balk at the idea of prac­tic­ing it our­selves. Per­haps we fear that med­i­ta­tion is too new agey, or it might slow us down or lead to com­pla­cen­cy. Some might fear mind­ful­ness could come at the expense of pro­duc­tiv­i­ty, a moral com­pass, or even the vital­i­ty that gives us our edge.

But new research stud­ies bust some of the com­mon myths around mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion. Rather than mak­ing us bliss­ful­ly tuned out or care­free, mind­ful­ness med­i­ta­tion may actu­al­ly make it eas­i­er for us to take a moral stand, be per­sis­tent in achiev­ing our goals, and be more ener­getic in our lives—even our sex lives!

Here are some of the myths of mind­ful­ness and the research that coun­ter­acts those myths.

Myth #1: Mindfulness meditation makes you turn inward and become more isolated

When I first heard about mind­ful­ness, this was a con­cern of mine. Will I turn into some kind of new-age per­son who is, frankly, self-absorbed and kind of out of it?

Appar­ent­ly not, say the results of sev­er­al research stud­ies. If any­thing, mind­ful­ness makes our social rela­tion­ships stronger—perhaps by help­ing us to bet­ter reg­u­late dif­fi­cult emo­tions like anger or resent­ment. And, though mind­ful­ness may be devel­oped via an inward prac­tice like med­i­ta­tion, it still helps us to con­nect with the suf­fer­ing of oth­ers and want to reach out to help them—something that def­i­nite­ly builds social cap­i­tal.

In one recent study, par­tic­i­pants were assigned to wit­ness a sce­nario in which one play­er was exclud­ed from a dig­i­tal ball game. Through some clever designs, the researchers were able to show that peo­ple who did a very brief mind­ful­ness prac­tice were more like­ly to express sym­pa­thy to the exclud­ed play­er and to throw the ball to them more often in a sub­se­quent game. In fact, neu­ro­science stud­ies show that you can active­ly prac­tice hav­ing more com­pas­sion for oth­ers through mind­ful­ness prac­tices, and it seems to affect your brain in ways that make you more attuned to their suf­fer­ing and more like­ly to help.

So, rather than turn­ing you inward, it seems as if mind­ful­ness could be a use­ful social glue and actu­al­ly strength­en rela­tion­ships. It may even have more impact if you med­i­tate togeth­er.

Myth #2: Mindfulness meditation wears down your “grit”

Hav­ing “grit”—being able to per­sist toward our goals, even when things get rough—is some­thing many of us strive for. It’s a qual­i­ty that’s val­ued at work, in school, and in life. But one could argue that mindfulness—with its focus on accept­ing “what is”—might keep us from car­ing about goals or push­ing our­selves to achieve.

How­ev­er, a recent study says oth­er­wise. Stu­dents who report­ed being more mind­ful over­all were found to be more “grit­ty” four months lat­er, while the reverse wasn’t true—meaning, being grit­ti­er didn’t pre­dict lat­er mind­ful­ness. Cer­tain aspects of mind­ful­ness seemed to be key to this con­nec­tion; being “non-judg­ing” (of your expe­ri­ences, thoughts, and emo­tions) was tied to greater per­se­ver­ance, and “act­ing with aware­ness” (the abil­i­ty to focus your atten­tion on your activ­i­ties rather than doing things mind­less­ly or auto­mat­i­cal­ly) was tied to main­tain­ing inter­est in goals over time.

Though this study involved a large­ly homo­ge­neous group of par­tic­i­pants, oth­er stud­ies have found a con­nec­tion between mind­ful­ness and grit in more diverse set­tings, includ­ing non-West­ern cultures—though the effects were some­what weak­er in col­lec­tivist cul­tures ver­sus indi­vid­u­al­is­tic ones. In addi­tion, stud­ies have found that more mind­ful peo­ple (or peo­ple who train in mind­ful­ness) per­sist more on a dif­fi­cult task, are more engaged at work, and are less impul­sive, which may be con­nect­ed to grit, too.

Over­all, these results sug­gest that mind­ful­ness doesn’t pre­vent us from pur­su­ing our goals, but may actu­al­ly help us with them…though more (and bet­ter) research is cer­tain­ly need­ed to prove that.

Myth #3: Mindfulness meditation makes you overly mellow

Med­i­ta­tion seems to involve a lot of sitting—perhaps the excep­tion being mind­ful walk­ing. So, I wor­ry that all that sit­ting around will just zap my ener­gy and make me feel slug­gish.

But research seems to sug­gest the oppo­site. In one study, researchers found that when par­tic­i­pants went through a six-week mind­ful­ness pro­gram, they report­ed sig­nif­i­cant­ly greater vitality—as well as less per­son­al distress—than those who were in a con­trol group. Far from de-ener­giz­ing them, the mind­ful­ness prac­tices actu­al­ly kick­start­ed their ener­gy lev­els.

Many stud­ies have found that mind­ful­ness can improve sleep qual­i­ty, too—even in old­er adults who may tend toward insomnia—which cer­tain­ly would lead to greater live­li­ness the next day. And a more recent study sug­gests that peo­ple who are more mind­ful, whether sin­gle or part­nered, have greater sex­u­al satisfaction—a mark­er of vig­or for many peo­ple.

Myth #4: Mindfulness meditation makes you morally ambivalent

If mind­ful­ness is about accept­ing our present expe­ri­ence with­out judg­ment, we might think that prac­tic­ing it would make it dif­fi­cult to dis­cern right from wrong. If every­thing is good just as it is, why would we think any behav­ior is bad?

But, in fact, mind­ful­ness may actu­al­ly make us more dis­cern­ing about moral behav­ior.

In a recent study, busi­ness stu­dents were ran­dom­ly assigned to either an eight-week mind­ful­ness course or a course in self-man­age­ment (includ­ing emo­tion­al intel­li­gence, trust, and cre­ative think­ing). Then, they were test­ed on their moral rea­son­ing levels—or, how well they thought through moral dilem­mas. Researchers pre­sent­ed them with a moral­ly chal­leng­ing sce­nario, like being asked by a boss to ignore an ille­gal trans­ac­tion you uncov­ered between your firm and a favored client. Then, researchers asked them a series of ques­tions, includ­ing what they would do in that sit­u­a­tion and why. Their answers were record­ed, and their moral rea­son­ing was eval­u­at­ed by inde­pen­dent raters.

Addi­tion­al­ly, the stu­dents report­ed on how com­pas­sion­ate and ego­cen­tric they were before and after the course—saying how much they agreed with state­ments like “I often have ten­der feel­ings toward peo­ple (strangers) when they seem to be in need” or “Some­times you have to lie to get what you want.” After run­ning analy­ses, the researchers found that stu­dents receiv­ing mind­ful­ness train­ing became more com­pas­sion­ate and less ego­cen­tric, and they had high­er moral rea­son­ing skills than those receiv­ing self-man­age­ment lessons. This sug­gests that mind­ful­ness might improve moral reasoning—a pre­cur­sor to bet­ter behavior—by help­ing stu­dents to care more about oth­ers.

Oth­er stud­ies have found sim­i­lar results, though this line of research is rel­a­tive­ly new. Still, mind­ful­ness does seem to decrease ego­cen­trism and increase com­pas­sion, both of which seem like­ly to lead to more eth­i­cal behav­ior.

So, while you may wor­ry that suc­cumb­ing to the mind­ful med­i­ta­tion craze will some­how drain your ener­gy, turn you into an iso­lat­ed monk, com­pro­mise your moral­i­ty, or make you less pro­duc­tive, rest assured—it prob­a­bly won’t. Who knows? Like many before you, maybe you’ll move from being a skep­tic to a fan.

— Jill Sut­tie, Psy.D., is Greater Good‘s  book review edi­tor and a fre­quent con­trib­u­tor to the mag­a­zine. Based at UC-Berke­ley, Greater Good high­lights ground break­ing sci­en­tif­ic research into the roots of com­pas­sion and altru­ism. Copy­right Greater Good

Related reading:


Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Categories: Cognitive Neuroscience, Peak Performance, Professional Development, Technology

Tags: , , ,

Search in our archives

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters,  SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking how brain science can improve our health and our lives.

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)