Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Icon

Study: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) + Medication outperforms CBT alone to treat ADHD symptoms among adults. At the same time…

adult_adhdAlthough med­ica­tion is the pri­ma­ry treat­ment for adults with ADHD, and has good empir­i­cal sup­port, many adults would rather not take it. For these adults with ADHD, it would be help­ful to know whether med­ica­tion is like­ly to pro­vide sig­nif­i­cant ben­e­fits above and beyond those they would gain from well-con­duct­ed ther­a­py, or whether they are like­ly to derive rough­ly equiv­a­lent ben­e­fits from ther­a­py alone.

This impor­tant ques­tion was addressed in a recent­ly pub­lished study titled ‘Effi­ca­cy of cog­ni­tive behav­ioral ther­a­py with and with­out med­ica­tion for adults with ADHD: A ran­dom­ized con­trolled tri­al’. The study was pub­lished online in 2016 in the Jour­nal of Atten­tion Dis­or­ders. From the abstract:

  • Objec­tive: Recent tri­als have demon­strat­ed effi­ca­cy of cog­ni­tive behav­ioral ther­a­py (CBT) in med­icat­ed adults with ADHD. Effi­ca­cy of CBT in unmed­icat­ed ver­sus med­icat­ed adults remains most­ly unknown. We eval­u­at­ed the effects of group CBT alone ver­sus com­bined with med­ica­tion on ADHD symp­toms and func­tion­al out­comes in adult patients…Con­clu­sion: CBT + med­ica­tion out­per­formed CBT alone for ADHD symp­toms, orga­ni­za­tion­al skills, and self-esteem, although its supe­ri­or­i­ty tend­ed to decrease over fol­low-up.

The Study

Eighty-eight adults with care­ful­ly diag­nosed ADHD were ran­dom­ly assigned to receive 12 weeks of cog­ni­tive behav­ioral ther­a­py (CBT) alone, or CBT plus med­ica­tion. Over the 12 weeks, the fol­low­ing top­ics were addressed:

  1. Basic edu­ca­tion about ADHD and how it impacts adults.
  2. Goal set­ting and strate­gies for attain­ing goals.
  3. Orga­ni­za­tion and time man­age­ment.
  4. Man­ag­ing stress.
  5. Iden­ti­fy­ing and cor­rect­ing mal­adap­tive thoughts.
  6. Anger man­age­ment.
  7. Impulse con­trol and strate­gies for effec­tive self-reg­u­la­tion.
  8. Build­ing self-esteem.
  9. Under­stand­ing com­mon rela­tion­ship prob­lems in adults with ADHD and how to address them.

The pro­gram focused on the acqui­si­tion and prac­tice of adap­tive cog­ni­tive and behav­ioral skills to improve func­tion­ing in these areas. In addi­tion to didac­tic pre­sen­ta­tions on these top­ics, ses­sions were used to prac­tice new skills and iden­ti­fy ways to uti­lize new skills participants’daily lives. Par­tic­i­pants received week­ly home­work focused on imple­ment­ing the new­ly learned skills — this was an impor­tant part of the pro­gram.

Each par­tic­i­pant was also assigned a coach that they worked with through­out the pro­gram. Coach­es held twice week­ly phone calls with par­tic­i­pants in addi­tion to a brief face-to-face ses­sion. Dur­ing these coach­ing ses­sions, par­tic­i­pants and their coach dis­cussed the practice/implementation of new skills and dis­cussed ways to address bar­ri­ers to their imple­men­ta­tion.

Fol­low­ing the 12th ses­sion, there were 3 month­ly boost­er ses­sions ded­i­cat­ed to review­ing key con­cepts and trou­ble shoot­ing. Tele­phone coach­ing con­tin­ued dur­ing this time on a week­ly basis.

Med­ica­tion treat­ment — Adults assigned to the CBT + med­ica­tion group began on med­ica­tion pri­or to begin­ning CBT; they were start­ed on a low dose of stim­u­lant med­ica­tion that was grad­u­al­ly increased based on feed­back on effi­ca­cy and side effects. When fur­ther increas­es in dose did not enhance effi­ca­cy, or led to side effects, the pri­or dose was con­sid­ered opti­mal. They were main­tained on their opti­mal dose through­out the study and fol­low up peri­od. Adults who did not respond to the ini­tial stim­u­lant were tried on a dif­fer­ent stim­u­lant.

Mea­sures — A broad array of out­come mea­sures were includ­ed so that treat­ment impact on core ADHD symp­toms and func­tion­ing in impor­tant life domains could be exam­ined. The domains assessed includ­ed orga­ni­za­tion­al skills, self-esteem, symp­toms of depres­sion and anx­i­ety, anger expres­sion, and glob­al func­tion­ing. These were all self-report mea­sures that were com­plet­ed by adults them­selves. Core ADHD symp­toms were also rat­ed by an infor­mant that each adult select­ed, e.g., a spouse, part­ner, close friend, co-work­er, etc.

The mea­sures sum­ma­rized above were col­lect­ed at mul­ti­ple time points — at base­line, imme­di­ate­ly fol­low­ing med­ica­tion opti­miza­tion and before CBT began, after 12 weeks of CBT, fol­low­ing the 3-month boost­er peri­od, and a final time 3 months lat­er.

This data col­lec­tion sched­ule enabled the researchers to com­pare the 2 groups (CBT and CBT + meds) at mul­ti­ple time points to learn whether any ini­tial advan­tages found for either treat­ment were main­tained over time.

Results

ADHD symp­toms — Adults in the CBT + med­ica­tion group report­ed sig­nif­i­cant­ly greater reduc­tion in core ADHD symp­toms than adults receiv­ing CBT alone; this was evi­dent after the 12-week CBT treat­ment, after the 3-month boost­er end­ed, and at the final fol­low-up 3 months lat­er. Those who received CBT only also report­ed a sig­nif­i­cant reduc­tion in core symp­toms but this was less than for those who also received med­ica­tion.

When observ­er rat­ings were exam­ined, adults receiv­ing meds were also report­ed to show greater improve­ment in core symp­toms than adults receiv­ing CBT alone; this was evi­dent imme­di­ate­ly after CBT end­ed as well as after the 3-month boost­er. At the final assess­ment 3 months lat­er, how­ev­er, sig­nif­i­cant dif­fer­ences between the groups were no longer evi­dent.

Orga­ni­za­tion­al skills and self-esteem — Those in the CBT + meds group report­ed greater improve­ment in orga­ni­za­tion­al skills fol­low­ing the CBT ses­sions as well as after the 3-month boost­er; at the final assess­ment 3 months lat­er, how­ev­er, these dif­fer­ences were no longer sig­nif­i­cant. A sim­i­lar pat­tern was found for self-report­ed self-esteem. Thus, for these out­comes, those receiv­ing CBT + meds improved more quick­ly, but by the final mea­sure­ment point adults in the oth­er groups had ‘caught up’.

Depres­sion, anx­i­ety, anger expres­sion, and glob­al func­tion­ing — For these mea­sures, there was a trend towards improve­ment in both groups with no dif­fer­ences between them.

Summary and implications

Does med­ica­tion pro­vide sig­nif­i­cant addi­tion­al ben­e­fits to adults with ADHD above those pro­vid­ed by a good course of CBT alone? Results from this study indi­cate there is not a clear answer to this ques­tion as it depends on what out­comes are being con­sid­ered and the time frame in which they are being looked at.

For sev­er­al out­comes mea­sures — core ADHD symp­toms, orga­ni­za­tion, and self-esteem — those receiv­ing CBT + meds improved more quick­ly; that is not sur­pris­ing giv­en that the pos­i­tive effects of med­ica­tion are imme­di­ate while those result­ing from ther­a­py are like­ly to build over time. It was only for ADHD symp­toms, how­ev­er, that the incre­men­tal ben­e­fits of meds tend­ed to per­sist and this was only when con­sid­er­ing self-report and not observ­er rat­ings.

For the oth­er out­comes, i.e., depres­sion, anx­i­ety, anger expres­sion, and glob­al func­tion­ing, no addi­tion­al ben­e­fits from meds were evi­dent. The authors point out that this may have been because par­tic­i­pants were not clin­i­cal­ly ele­vat­ed on these mea­sures to begin with, so there was less room to show improve­ment.

What gen­er­al con­clu­sions can be drawn from this study? For adults whose dif­fi­cul­ties relat­ed to ADHD are acute, a tri­al of med­ica­tion seems very impor­tant. The impact on core symp­toms and on sev­er­al impor­tant func­tion­al domains is like­ly to be much quick­er; this can be espe­cial­ly impor­tant when some­one is real­ly strug­gling. Although those receiv­ing CBT only gen­er­al­ly caught up by the end of the study, this was more than a full year out (4 months CBT, 3 months of boost­er ses­sion, and final fol­low-up 3 months lat­er). For those whose ADHD is sig­nif­i­cant­ly impair­ing their day-to-day life, the time required for mean­ing­ful improve­ments with CBT alone may be too great.

For adults whose ADHD relat­ed dif­fi­cul­ties are less acute, and who do not wish to take meds, results indi­cat­ed that well-con­duct­ed CBT plus coach­ing is like­ly to pro­duce sig­nif­i­cant ben­e­fits in how they expe­ri­ence their lives; this will like­ly occur grad­u­al­ly over an extend­ed time peri­od. For many indi­vid­u­als, this more grad­ual reduc­tion in symp­toms and impair­ment may be fine.

Two impor­tant points qual­i­fy the above. First, except for observ­er rat­ings of core ADHD symp­toms, all out­comes were based on self-report and some would sug­gest that these are not objec­tive assess­ments. Thus, includ­ing more objec­tive assess­ments of dif­fer­ent out­comes when fea­si­ble would have strength­ened the study.

Sec­ond, it is impor­tant to note that the CBT pro­vid­ed was quite an exten­sive treat­ment — week­ly group ses­sions and mul­ti­ple week­ly coach­ing ses­sion for 4 month fol­lowed by month­ly boost­ers over anoth­er 3 months. To be can­did, it could be dif­fi­cult to pro­cure this treat­ment in many com­mu­ni­ties; med­ica­tion, of course, is avail­able pret­ty much every­where.

Thus, chal­lenges to obtain­ing good non-med­ical treat­ment for ADHD is a real issue that must be addressed for indi­vid­u­als to more eas­i­ly real­ize the ben­e­fits that such treat­ment can pro­vide.

Rabiner_David– Dr. David Rabin­er is a child clin­i­cal psy­chol­o­gist and Direc­tor of Under­grad­u­ate Stud­ies in the Depart­ment of Psy­chol­ogy and Neu­ro­science at Duke Uni­ver­sity. He pub­lishes the Atten­tion Research Update, an online newslet­ter that helps par­ents, pro­fes­sion­als, and edu­ca­tors keep up with the lat­est research on ADHD, and helped pre­pare the self-paced, online course How to Nav­i­gate Con­ven­tion­al and Com­ple­men­tary ADHD Treat­ments for Healthy Brain Devel­op­ment.

Relat­ed read­ing:

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Categories: Attention and ADD/ADHD, Cognitive Neuroscience

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters and more, SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking health and performance applications of brain science.

Follow us and Engage via…

twitter_logo_header
RSS Feed

Search for anything brain-related in our article archives