• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Tracking Health and Wellness Applications of Brain Science

Spanish
sb-logo-with-brain
  • Resources
    • Monthly eNewsletter
    • Solving the Brain Fitness Puzzle
    • The SharpBrains Guide to Brain Fitness
    • How to evaluate brain training claims
    • Resources at a Glance
  • Brain Teasers
    • Top 25 Brain Teasers & Games for Teens and Adults
    • Brain Teasers for each Cognitive Ability
    • More Mind Teasers & Games for Adults of any Age
  • Virtual Summits
    • 2019 SharpBrains Virtual Summit
    • Speaker Roster
    • Brainnovations Pitch Contest
    • 2017 SharpBrains Virtual Summit
    • 2016 SharpBrains Virtual Summit
    • 2015 SharpBrains Virtual Summit
    • 2014 SharpBrains Virtual Summit
  • Report: Pervasive Neurotechnology
  • Report: Digital Brain Health
  • About
    • Mission & Team
    • Endorsements
    • Public Speaking
    • In the News
    • Contact Us

Brain Training @ BBC/ Nature: Fact, Hope, Hype?

April 19, 2010 by Alvaro Fernandez

Update (04/20/10): after read­ing the full BBC study in Nature, I wrote the arti­cle titled BBC “Brain Train­ing” Exper­i­ment: the Good, the Bad, the Ugly, say­ing that “you prob­a­bly saw the hun­dreds of media arti­cles titled “brain train­ing doesn’t work”, based on a BBC exper­i­ment. Once more, claims seem to go beyond the sci­ence back­ing them up … except that in this case it is the researchers, not the devel­op­ers, who are respon­si­ble.” You can keep read­ing full updat­ed arti­cle Here.

Below is what I orig­i­nal­ly wrote before the paper itself was available.

—

Tomor­row we’ll prob­a­bly wit­ness brainpica lot of media cov­er­age about a exper­i­ment run by the BBC in the UK, to be pub­lished in Nature, on whether “brain train­ing” works.

The paper is still embar­goed, so we can­not com­ment on it, but what I can do is to share frag­ments of my email to a BBC reporter six months ago, dis­cussing impres­sions on what they had announced as the ulti­mate test of whether “brain train­ing” works.

Again, these were pure­ly my impres­sions based on lim­it­ed pub­lic infor­ma­tion. Once we can com­ment on the pub­lished paper we’ll be able to pro­vide a more informed perspective.

“Hel­lo XYZ,

Here go some of my thoughts based on my exter­nal per­cep­tion of your test:

  • I agree with many of the premis­es for the test
  • But “Does brain train­ing real­ly work” is a high­ly mis­lead­ing frame: the obvi­ous answer is, yes, it works as a cat­e­go­ry. If not, do you mean peo­ple can’t learn? med­i­tate? go through cog­ni­tive ther­a­py? cog­ni­tive retrain­ing? increase work­ing mem­o­ry and oth­er brain func­tions? All these are estab­lished beyond doubt through dozens of well-con­trolled stud­ies where the inter­ven­tion effect a) goes beyond place­bo, and b) remains there once train­ing is over. The 2009 report I sent you includes 10 Research Exec­u­tive Briefs by lead­ing sci­en­tists who ref­er­ence pub­lished papers in high-qual­i­ty jour­nals. None eval­u­ates Nin­ten­do — but should they be ignored, as a group?
  • Now, the key ques­tions are, “what spe­cif­ic brain train­ing are we talk­ing about”, “work for what?” and “work for whom?”. That’s where we could help edu­cate con­sumers sep­a­rate hope from hype.
  • …Right now you are invent­ing your own “brain game”, and the only thing you will test is whether that spe­cif­ic “brain game” you have devel­op “works” or not (not clear what out­come mea­sures you have). I would­n’t dare to man­u­fac­ture my own car now from scratch and claim, based on the results, that “cars” work or don’t.
  • I could­n’t agree more with “brain train­ing that is good for one per­son might not be good for you”, since one of “brain train­ing” prop­er­ties (both strength and weak­ness) is its high­ly tar­get­ed nature. The impli­ca­tion? we need bet­ter assess­ments to pin­point bot­tle­necks and direct appro­pri­ate inter­ven­tion. con­sumers need bet­ter edu­ca­tion and infor­ma­tion to know what is a waste of time and mon­ey and what may be wor­thy. Yet, your test seems to ful­ly ignore this, and test whether the same thing is good for everyone…you may be throw­ing out the baby with the water…”

Your thoughts?

(Will link to paper once pub­lished). Relat­ed articles:

  • Does Cog­ni­tive Train­ing Work? For whom? for what?
  • Are videogames good for you? It depends on who YOU are

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Pock­et

Filed Under: Technology & Innovation Tagged With: BBC, Brain-Training, fact, hope, hype, nature

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Tiffany Wismer says

    April 22, 2010 at 3:00

    Brain train­ing has many facets, and requires spe­cif­ic envi­ron­ments and applied tech­niques to real­ly work effec­tive­ly. But when it’s done right, it *does* work. Learn­ingRx has seen thou­sands of kids’ lives changed by brain training. 

    If any­one is inter­est­ed in know­ing more, our founder, Dr. Ken Gib­son, respond­ed to the find­ings of the nature jour­nal study here: http://www.learningrxblog.com/nature-journal-brain-training-study/

  2. Martin Walker says

    May 3, 2010 at 4:00

    To extend your anal­o­gy, I think the BBC team, under the guid­ance of Dr. Owens, set out to build a car that would­n’t get down the block. Dr. Owens designed a brain train­ing regime that mim­ic­ked the casu­al, divert­ing games sold by the likes of Nin­ten­do. The pur­pose of the study seems to have been to debunk this genre of brain train­ing rather than to seri­ous­ly answer the ques­tion it claimed to pose.

    Mar­tin

Primary Sidebar

Top Articles on Brain Health and Neuroplasticity

  1. Can you grow your hippocampus? Yes. Here’s how, and why it matters
  2. How learning changes your brain
  3. To harness neuroplasticity, start with enthusiasm
  4. Three ways to protect your mental health during –and after– COVID-19
  5. Why you turn down the radio when you're lost
  6. Solving the Brain Fitness Puzzle Is the Key to Self-Empowered Aging
  7. Ten neu­rotech­nolo­gies about to trans­form brain enhance­ment & health
  8. Five reasons the future of brain enhancement is digital, pervasive and (hopefully) bright
  9. What Educators and Parents Should Know About Neuroplasticity and Dance
  10. The Ten Habits of Highly Effective Brains
  11. Six tips to build resilience and prevent brain-damaging stress
  12. Can brain training work? Yes, if it meets these 5 conditions
  13. What are cognitive abilities and how to boost them?
  14. Eight Tips To Remember What You Read
  15. Twenty Must-Know Facts to Harness Neuroplasticity and Improve Brain Health

Top 10 Brain Teasers and Illusions

  1. You think you know the colors? Try the Stroop Test
  2. Check out this brief attention experiment
  3. Test your stress level
  4. Guess: Are there more brain connections or leaves in the Amazon?
  5. Quick brain teasers to flex two key men­tal mus­cles
  6. Count the Fs in this sentence
  7. Can you iden­tify Apple’s logo?
  8. Ten classic optical illu­sions to trick your mind
  9. What do you see?
  10. Fun Mental Rotation challenge
  • Check our Top 25 Brain Teasers, Games and Illusions

Join 12,619 readers exploring, at no cost, the latest in neuroplasticity and brain health.

By subscribing you agree to receive our free, monthly eNewsletter. We don't rent or sell emails collected, and you may unsubscribe at any time.

IMPORTANT: Please check your inbox or spam folder in a couple minutes and confirm your subscription.

Get In Touch!

Contact Us

660 4th Street, Suite 205,
San Francisco, CA 94107 USA

About Us

SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking health and performance applications of brain science. We prepare general and tailored market reports, publish consumer guides, produce an annual global and virtual conference, and provide strategic advisory services.

© 2022 SharpBrains. All Rights Reserved - Privacy Policy