Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


Brain Training and “Brain-ism” in Japan

Go HiranoToday we are trav­el­ing to Japan. Go Hira­no is a ser­i­al Japan­ese entre­pre­neur who has been explor­ing neu­ro­science-based oppor­tu­ni­ties in Japan, hav­ing recent­ly cre­at­ed the com­pa­ny NeuWell (neu­ro­science for well­ness).


Key take-aways:

- Peo­ple in Japan devour any prod­uct with brain-relat­ed claims

- But there has been a recent back­lash against chil­dren videogames, so game devel­op­ers have start­ed to focus on old­er audi­ences with (most­ly unproven) brain-health-improv­ing games

- The mar­ket is ripe for pro­grams with proven research and tan­gi­ble ben­e­fits


AF: Hira­no-san, tell us a bit about your­self and how you became inter­est­ed in applied neu­ro­science.

GH: after help­ing launch one of the first DSL providers in Japan, I start­ed to won­der what the next big­ger val­ue for soci­ety would be. I have always been fas­ci­nat­ed by brain research, so I start­ed to explore oppor­tu­ni­ties to help bring to mar­ket neu­ro­science-based pro­grams to help stu­dents do bet­ter in exams, and adults age in brain-friend­ly ways.

AF: what is the state of Brain Fit­ness and Brain Train­ing in Japan? what are the most pop­u­lar appli­ca­tions so far?

GH: I think peo­ple under­stand the con­cepts of Brain Fit­ness and Brain Train­ing. If one method or product/service sounds a bit sci­en­tif­ic there are peo­ple who would try it for fun and curios­i­ty. How­ev­er, major­i­ty of the peo­ple know that many exist­ing ones have low returns on efforts and time. So far, the most pop­u­lar appli­ca­tion was anti-aging, and prod­uct was Dr. Kawashima’s book of cal­cu­la­tions and oral read­ing for adults since it made peo­ple to get the con­cept of brain train­ing.

AF: Japan population’s aver­age age is get­ting old­er prob­a­bly at the fastest speed on earth, and peo­ple there have been exposed to videogames for a long while. How do peo­ple in Japan react towards pro­grams and games that make brain-relat­ed claims?

GH: In any book­store, there always is a sec­tion for brain books where you can find names like Takeshi Yoro, Takashi Tachibana, Ryu­ta Kawashima, Tony Buzan, Steven Pinker, V.S. Ramachan­dran and so on. TV vari­ety shows reg­u­lar­ly come up with Brain spe­cials. It is hard­ly deni­able that brains enchant Japan­ese peo­ple. We love brain train­ing.

Long before Dr. Ole­sen, Dr. West­er­berg and Dr. Torkel Kling­berg pub­lished their very-well-received paper about work­ing mem­o­ry train­ing (titled Increased pre­frontal and pari­etal activ­i­ty after train­ing of work­ing mem­o­ry), brain-train­ing ser­vices had been avail­able here. “Speed Lis­ten­ing” adver­tise­ments say “Why haven’t we come up with this idea before?”, and the idea is that by lis­ten­ing 2x speed, your brain works 2x faster. I believe it was there from the 70s and, even now inside the paper bag from book­shop you can find its brochure when you buy books. World pop­u­lar speed-read­ing has its Japan­ese ver­sion of pro­pa­gan­da that it not only speeds up your read­ing but also your brain and even “acti­vates” your right brain. This is not based on actu­al research, but many peo­ple believe it.

There were two times of “brain boom” in the past and Brain Imag­ing cre­at­ed a third one most recent­ly. Dr. Kawashima claimed cal­cu­la­tions and oral read­ing are good to devel­op kids’ brains in the book for chil­dren “Jibun no Nou wo Jibun de Sodateru (Devel­op your own brain)” in 2001. In the book, gam­ing was said to reduce pre­frontal acti­va­tion and have bad or no ben­e­fit for kid’s brain. He com­pared the fMRI image of some­one doing sim­ple cal­cu­la­tions and play­ing games, and appar­ent­ly the image of the for­mer showed more activ­i­ties. To see the activ­i­ties inside the brain was fresh for peo­ple, but the method­ol­o­gy and log­ic was not reviewed by any sci­en­tif­ic pub­li­ca­tion. It was pub­lished by a com­pa­ny that pro­vides a fran­chised chain of learn­ing class­es. The com­pa­ny main­tained books at book­stores to cre­ate a boom and was very suc­cess­ful. Then they came up with adult ver­sion of train­ing book, and sold more than 2 mil­lion. Adults and senior peo­ple were seri­ous­ly did addi­tion and sub­trac­tion of 1 dig­it num­bers for count­less times believ­ing it will main­tain and even enhance their brain­pow­er.

This then became the basis for the Brain Age video game (AF’s note: this is a game that is sell­ing very well in Europe and the USA). More recent­ly from him, cook­ing became good for brain since cook­ing demands plan­ning and mul­ti­ple tasks. They demand pre­frontal cor­tex acti­va­tion, and he showed image of a brain when cook­ing. A gas com­pa­ny that wants to sell more gas ranges and ovens helped spon­sor the research.

AF: we have heard there has been a back­lash recent­ly. Is it more of a sci­en­tif­ic, or con­sumer one?

GH: Sci­en­tif­ic for adults’ games, con­sumer for kids’ ones. In 2001, anoth­er researcher, Dr. Akio Mori wrote an arti­cle called “Gemu(=Game) Nou(=Brain) no Kyofu (The Fear of Game Brain)”. He cre­at­ed his own EEG machine and gath­ered the data of peo­ple who fre­quent­ly play games and peo­ple who do not. He found the “beta-wave” from fre­quent game play­ers that are “same as senior peo­ple with demen­tia”. That, he said, is because of lack of activ­i­ties in their pre­frontal cor­tex, and that means more prob­a­bil­i­ties for low­er aca­d­e­m­ic per­for­mance and crime. Though his equip­ment was not ver­i­fied, and he was said to get con­fused about alpha and beta wave of EEG, par­ents and edu­ca­tion author­i­ties like munic­i­pal edu­ca­tion com­mit­tees loved his book and invit­ed him for lec­tures and con­fer­ences. His new book in 2006 became the rec­om­mend­ed book of the year from the Nation­al PTA Com­mit­tee.

The sales of soft­ware on home game machines have declined from its peak of 533 bil­lion yen in 1997 to its 53%, 315 bil­lion yen in 2005. Dr. Mori’s book and phe­nom­e­na was the fin­ish­ing blow to the indus­try, espe­cial­ly for kids’ games. There­fore game com­pa­nies had to find new tar­gets who had nev­er played game machines, like mid­dle-aged group and women. Brain Age was pre­ced­ed by a Sega’s game box that was the nat­ur­al next step after the book from Dr. Kawashima I men­tioned.

For women, games on Eng­lish train­ing, lan­guage sup­port for trav­el­ing, cook­ing, com­mon sense and eti­quette are pro­vid­ed. These new sort of seri­ous games not only helped the hand­held game machine stay always out of stock and reach mul­ti-mil­lion sales, but also suc­cess­ful­ly gave the image that games are, depend­ing on the soft­ware, good for the brain and edu­ca­tion. Fun­ny it is that the author­i­ty back­ing the cam­paign is the same Dr. Kawashima who orig­i­nal­ly rec­om­mend­ed kids to cal­cu­late rather than to play games for the ben­e­fit for brains.

No won­der, author­i­ties from the aca­d­e­m­ic and med­ical soci­eties of the neu­ro­science field start­ed crit­i­ciz­ing sci­en­tif­i­cal­ly unproven or no evi­dence-based prod­ucts, books and opin­ion mak­ers. This year, neu­ro­science researchers start­ed a group called “Nou wo Ika­su (Make the best out of Neu­ro­science)” and have fre­quent meet­ings of researchers where peo­ple can join. I vis­it­ed one of those and saw par­tic­i­pants were busy not only crit­i­ciz­ing them but also hint­ing that autho­riza­tion cri­te­ria by neu­ro­sci­en­tists are being pre­pared.

How­ev­er, adult con­sumers keep devour­ing such games. Dentsu, the biggest adver­tis­ing agency announced the No.1 Con­sumer-cho­sen Choice of the Prod­uct 2006 was game soft­ware and books for brain train­ing. So far, appar­ent­ly the demands went far out before the real neu­ro­science comes to fill. Between the bal­ance of body and brain, Japan­ese peo­ple are one of the extreme that is most brain-ism ori­ent­ed, to the brain side, says Dr. Yoro. It seems we, brain-ism extrem­ists, can­not wait the real neu­ro­science to come.

AF: what would you sug­gest that non-Japan­ese com­pa­nies do if they want to bring their pro­grams to Japan?

GH: I would sug­gest to define and attack from a tar­get where you can pro­vide very tan­gi­ble val­ue based on sci­en­tif­ic facts. If you already have actu­al results in US or your mar­ket, they will work. Peo­ple are tired of “just for fun” prod­ucts and wait for results that is worth effort and time based on sci­ence. Since the demands are mount­ing, com­mu­ni­ca­tion and good research is all what mat­ters. Since neu­ro­sci­en­tists are ner­vous about “Far Out” prod­ucts, prod­ucts’ research back­ground will be asked more than past.

AF: what are some spe­cif­ic neu­ro­science-based pro­grams that you think may find a mar­ket in Japan?

GH: We are very excit­ed about the poten­tial to intro­duce Cogmed Work­ing Mem­o­ry Train­ing here in Japan, where the ADD/ ADHD prob­lem is becom­ing more acknowl­edged. Also, giv­en that being stu­dent here is very stress­ful, we think biofeed­back-based pro­grams for peak per­for­mance and stress man­age­ment may be very help­ful to improve over­all learn­ing and test per­for­mance. Not only for stu­dents, but also for traders-we are fol­low­ing with great atten­tion Sharp­Brains’ series of inter­views and posts based on Brett N. Steen­barg­er’s research on Trad­er Per­for­mance and The Psy­chol­o­gy of Trad­ing.

AF: Go, thanks for updat­ing us on what is going on in Japan. Please keep us informed.

GH: I will hap­pi­ly do so. We will soon have ready an Eng­lish web­site and blog.

AF: We will glad­ly let our read­ers know when those are ready.

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

11 Responses

  1. alexandra says:

    I’d like to add a new twist to the brain game con­ver­sa­tion. How about brain teasers that include sweat­ing! What good is train­ing one’s brain if it does­n’t include get­ting the body to move. I think the rea­son so many peo­ple are couch pota­toes is because they haven’t engaged their brains first in activ­i­ties that make their bod­ies want to fol­low. I have been involved in a fit­ness activ­i­ty for the past 15 years that “teas­es” my mind first and I become so engaged with learn­ing that the next thing I know I am sweat­ing and have just got­ten a healthy, anti-aging (check out my pho­tos on the web­site and guess how old I am)fun work­out. Get off the couch and start mov­ing your brain.

  2. Alvaro says:

    Hi Alexan­dra,

    Most­ly agreed. We have men­tioned many times that phys­i­cal exer­cise is impor­tant. Now, what many peo­ple don’t know is that the brain also needs exer­cise-and as of today the best research-based brain train­ing pro­grams hap­pen to be com­put­er-based and need full atten­tion, so they need to be done on their own.

    In the future, we will be able to com­bine men­tal exer­cise with phys­i­cal one. Feel free to share more infor­ma­tion on how specif­i­cal­ly that pro­gram includes the “teas­ing” ele­ment. Thanks

  3. Dr. Kawashima’s book ‘Train Your Brain’ posi­tions his brain train­ing approach as a rem­e­dy for Alzheimers. That claim seems sus­pect, and doubt­less were his claims real­is­tic, there would be a sweep­ing noise made over it, and cer­tain­ly he’d be high­ly praised in the Sci­en­tif­ic Com­mu­ni­ty for such a break­through.

    Is there any peer-reviewed data avail­able to sub­stan­ti­ate the claims, and have they been sup­port­ed by cred­i­ble researchers?

  4. Alvaro says:

    Hel­lo Ter­ral,

    There is no “rem­e­dy for Alzheimer’s”, so Dr. Kawashima’s pro­grams aren’t one, cer­tain­ly. At least in the US, Nin­ten­do is not mak­ing any spe­cif­ic health claims: Nin­ten­do Brain Age should be seen as a fun and stim­u­lat­ing game, noth­ing more noth­ing less.

    Now, there is research that sug­gests lead­ing a men­tal­ly stim­u­lat­ing life can reduce the prob­a­bil­i­ty of devel­op­ing Alzheimer’s symp­toms, so why not play Nin­ten­do, or take on gar­den­ing, or trav­el to new coun­tries…

    Please take into account that this is dif­fer­ent from the pro­grams that have peer-reviewed research show­ing they can train and improve spe­cif­ic cog­ni­tive skills.

Leave a Reply to Terral Lawrence × Cancel reply

Categories: Education & Lifelong Learning, Health & Wellness, Neuroscience Interview Series, Technology

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About SharpBrains

As seen in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, BBC News, CNN, Reuters,  SharpBrains is an independent market research firm tracking how brain science can improve our health and our lives.

Search in our archives

Follow us and Engage via…

RSS Feed

Watch All Recordings Now (40+ Speakers, 12+ Hours)