Sharp Brains: Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News

Neuroplasticity, Brain Fitness and Cognitive Health News


Alzheimer’s Disease: too serious to play with headlines

Featured Website, Scientific American Mind, June/July 2007

We just came across an arti­cle titled Best Com­puter Brain Games for Senior Cit­i­zens to Delay Alzheimer’s Dis­ease. The head­line makes lit­tle sci­en­tific sense-and we observe this con­fu­sion often. The arti­cle men­tions a few pro­grams we have dis­cussed often in this blog, such as Posit Sci­ence and Mind­Fit, and oth­ers we haven’t because we haven’t found any pub­lished sci­ence behind, such as Dakim and MyBrain­Trainer. And there are more pro­grams: what about Happy Neu­ron, Lumos­ity, Spry Learn­ing and Captain’s Log. Not to talk about Nin­tendo Brain Age, of course.

Some of those pro­grams have real sci­ence that, at best, shows how some spe­cific cog­ni­tive skills (like mem­ory, or atten­tion, or pro­cess­ing) can be trained and improved-no mat­ter the age. This is a very impor­tant mes­sage that hasn’t yet per­co­lated through many brains out there: we know today that computer-based soft­ware pro­grams can be very use­ful to train some cog­ni­tive skills, bet­ter than alter­na­tive meth­ods (paper and pen­cil, classroom-based, just “daily living”).

Now, no sin­gle pro­gram can make ANY claim that it specif­i­cally delays/ pre­vents Alzheimer’s Dis­ease beyond gen­eral state­ments such as that Learn­ing Slows Phys­i­cal Pro­gres­sion of Alzheimer’s Dis­ease (hence the imper­a­tive for life­long learn­ing) and that men­tal stimulation-together with other lifestyle fac­tors such as nutri­tion, phys­i­cal exer­cise and stress man­age­ment, as out­lined in these Steps to Improve Your Brain Health- may con­tribute to build a Cog­ni­tive Reserve that may reduce the prob­a­bil­ity of prob­lems. Pro­grams may be able to delay the appear­ance of some symp­toms, but we don’t know yet how to delay the dis­ease. And there is no evi­dence that one par­tic­u­lar pro­gram is bet­ter than another for that pur­pose of delay­ing the dis­ease. Or bet­ter than learn­ing Chi­nese, or play­ing the vio­lin, for that mat­ter. You can can read more at our pre­vi­ous post on Does a brain fit­ness pro­gram pre­vent Alzheimer’s dis­ease and other forms of dementia?

Given this con­text, and the impor­tance of the topic, we are happy to see the birth of the Healthy Brain Ini­tia­tive by CDC and Alzheimer’s Asso­ci­a­tion. We are sure that research will start to accu­mu­late and guide efforts to delay demen­tias. For the time being, in our view, we should view brain fit­ness pro­grams as use­ful tools to train and develop spe­cific skills, whether it is audi­tory pro­cess­ing in the case of Posit Sci­ence, a vari­ety of them at Mind­Fit, work­ing mem­ory at Cogmed, periph­eral vision and oth­ers through Intel­li­gym. We can improve our qual­ity of life, pro­duc­tiv­ity and men­tal fac­ul­ties. All these tools prob­a­bly help to reduce the prob­a­bil­ity of devel­op­ing Alzheimer’s and other demen­tias (so I per­son­ally make sure to learn new things and skills as often as I can, and using these tools is part of that), but that shouldn’t be the main rea­son why peo­ple use them since it is an indi­rect rela­tion­ship at this point.

For more infor­ma­tion, the National Insti­tute on Aging pro­vides a great arti­cle on Can Alzheimer’s Dis­ease be Pre­vented?. And you can always con­sult our check­lists on How to Select the Right Brain Fit­ness Pro­gram (short ver­sion and full one) for guid­ance, or review the post Mind­Fit and Posit Sci­ence in the Wall Street Journal’s “Putting Brain Exer­cises to the Test”.

In short: long live life­long learn­ing and neu­ro­plas­tic­ity! long live good lifestyle habits! just take Alzheimer’s-related claims with a whole shaker of salt.

Leave a Reply...

Loading Facebook Comments ...

4 Responses

  1. […] Alvaro Fer­nan­dez presents Alzheimer’s Dis­ease: too seri­ous to play with head­lines posted at Sharp­Brains, say­ing, “Brain Fit­ness pro­grams can do many things…but no mir­a­cles, unfortunately.” […]

  2. […] He’s not a nurse, but Alvaro Fer­nan­dez presents some good link­age in his post on Alzheimer’s Dis­ease: Too Seri­ous to Play With Head­lines posted at Brain Fit­ness. Many nurses deal with Alzheimer’s patients on a daily basis, so I’m includ­ing this post for all of us! […]

  3. […] — Life­long learn­ing and brain exercise/ men­tal stimulation have been shown to reduce the prob­a­bil­ity of devel­op­ing Alzheimer’s-related symp­toms as we age. Now, no one spe­cific pro­gram has shown so far that it is bet­ter than another one in this regard. Some pro­grams have shown good results at train­ing and improv­ing spe­cific cog­ni­tive skills, which is dif­fer­ent. You can learn more at Alzheimer’s Dis­ease: too seri­ous to play with headlines. […]

  4. […] If you want to learn more: review of our own skep­ti­cism regard­ing some claims, inter­view notes with neu­ro­sci­en­tists behind mil­i­tary and bas­ket­ball train­ing applications and work­ing mem­ory train­ing for kids with ADD/ ADHD. […]

Categories: Cognitive Neuroscience, Health & Wellness

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,